I probably know too much about the Disney Princess canon in the first place so it was a surprise when I rewatched Enchanted for the first time in a while and realized, or remembered, Giselle is a Disney character. But not an official Disney Princess!
And frankly I don’t think she -or her movie- gets her due.
Enchanted was a pretty darned successful and enjoyable movie when it came out. It’s about your typical Disney animated fairy tale girl wonderfully played by Amy Adams who is cursed by a wicked witch and becomes a “real” woman stuck in New York City.
Prince Charming (the underrated in nearly everything but especially this James Marsden) comes after her but not before she meets a handsome lawyer (Patrick Dempsey) and the de facto cute kid who, in the most unbelievable part of any Disney movie, takes her home and lets her stay the night despite the fact she’s seemingly in the middle of a break with reality in his mind.
The movie also stars Susan Sarandon as the Witch and Idina Menzel (the future Elsa) as Robert’s girlfriend.
So it has a great cast.
Giselle also has many other trappings of a first rate Disney Princess:
Okay the first unanimated dress is a bit much and the park scene dress maybe a bit too cutesy but it’s wearable. And I would wear everything in this movie but the big ball gown.
She’s got great music. Fun dance numbers. I swear no matter how long it’s been since I watched the movie Happy Working Song is always on my Be Happy playlist.
A witch. A dragon.
And like most great Disney stuff it shamelessly and knowingly “borrows” from all the Princesses that came before her.
And it does have that cringe scene in the lobby of Robert’s office where Giselle asks the woman if she can touch her hair.
It’s classic Disney.
So why doesn’t Enchanted get more love?
I think it comes down to sex and animation.
Enchanted is the first and only Disney “Princess” movie where I’ve ever (super maturely) known, “These two are having sex.”
I mean I’m sure you’re thinking technically most of them got married but come on… do you really look at Cinderella and think heck yes she and the Prince had a sex life? Does anybody think that or is my over stressed brain just losing it?
To be honest even in the recent live action versions I don’t buy it. I mean after I watched Beauty and the Beast all I could really think at the end was Emma Watson was probably thinking, “Oh go back to being the Beast!” I liked Lily James and Richard Madden in the live-action Cinderella but again there was like no chemistry or tension and they probably just spent happily ever after obsessing over how adorable they are.
But Enchanted did push it a bit with the after shower scene and Dempsey and Adams had enough chemistry to make me go… yep they’re hot for each other.
And now the reason why it’s most likely Giselle and Enchanted don’t get their due with the legendary Disney Princesses (that’s not you know out of my dirty mind) she’s simply not animated enough.
Really the animated section of the film probably amounts to all of 7-10 minutes at most and it’s nice but not much time has been put into it. You couldn’t pick animated Giselle out of a line-up. Save for the park dress which speaks to the good costuming in my mind but otherwise perhaps if they ever get the sequel off the ground they’ll animate it more.
Of course Giselle might likely never be official a Disney Princess due to the rights issues (ie securing the right to Amy Adams likeness forever) but that’s hardly fun to think about. I think it’s sex and animation.
But regardless I do hope to see a sequel one day. I think the film mainly holds up as a whole and it was fun singing down memory lane a bit.
8 thoughts on “Why Doesn’t Giselle Get Her Due?”
sequal would be cool! What I like about this movie is all in the scene where he tell her, It’s like your from a hallmark card. I say this story mkes us refect the businesses of life and how we are going around too grown up. Sure these characters are one extreme to the other but I say we could use a little hallmark in our days, just a little.
Giselle doesn’t get her due because this was live action so they can pretend she isn’t an official Disney Princess. I wish it got more love though, Enchanted was so much better than I expected it to be and Amy Adams was delightful.
I saw this movie recently. I didn’t know Idina Menzel played the witch.
She’s Robert’s girlfriend actually. Sarandon is the witch 🙂 She’s awesome in it.
I absolutely love Enchanted! It’s the original Frozen (in terms of subversion) that doesn’t get nearly enough credit. Last I read, Amy Adams’ likeness is the main reason why she wasn’t inducted into the official Disney Princess line up.
I wonder what the difference is between her and Emma Watson or the current live-action? Wouldn’t they need their likenesses to or is it that they still aren’t really the A squad? I mean as much as they may sell product with Emma Watson as Belle for instance I still think of the animated version first.
I think it’s just a matter of prolonged merchandising. The live-action remakes were just one movie. Animation will always stand out most in the end. Which is why they’re so iconic in that form.
Way to ruin my childhood, Gemma. I was happy never thinking about the fact that Cinderella and Prince Charming have sex. In my imagination, they just dance at balls and hold hands. That’s the limit.